Dick Cavett’s famed Montauk spread sells for $23.6M —a $38M discount

Real Estate

An iconic oceanfront Montauk home owned by legendary TV host Dick Cavett has sold for $23.6 million — far less than its original $62 million asking price in 2017.

The home, at 176 Deforest Road, is known as Tick Hall, and it is where Cavett entertained stars from Muhammad Ali to Tennessee Williams and Robert Redford. Locals have even called it Cavett’s Cove. 

The home was originally one of the Seven Sisters homes built by famed Gilded Age architect Stanford White in the early 1880s.

But the original home burned down in 1997, when a welder working on the roof sent a spark that tore through the property, taking down everything except a chimney.

Cavett rebuilt it from memory and friends’ photographs and building materials unearthed from the ashes — as no plans for it existed.

The rebuilding became a documentary, “From the Ashes: The Life and Times of Tick Hall.”  During the rebuilding, some modern additions were also added, like a bigger kitchen and screened porches.

An exterior of the home.
The Montauk home hosted such luminaries as Muhammad Ali and Robert Redford.
Chris Foster
An interior of the Montauk home.
Modern additions like an eat-in kitchen were added to the house.
Chris Foster
The Montauk home's pond.
There’s both a pond and a pool on the property.
Chris Foster

The six-bedroom, 6,500-square-foot home sits on 20 acres and is adjacent to a nearly 200-acre preserve.

The property includes a cliffside path with stairs that lead to a beach. There’s also a pond and a pool on the property, which Cavett bought in 1968 after renting there for years. 

A living space inside the home.
Cavett’s former home boasts 6,500 square feet.
Chris Foster
A porch at the Montauk home.
The new owner can rock out on Tick Hall’s porch.
Chris Foster

The listing broker is Chris Coleman of Compass.

 Brokers Krae Van Sickle and Lylla Carter of Saunders & Associates repped the buyer.  

Products You May Like

Articles You May Like

Woman reveals how property was stolen in identity theft real estate scam with ties to international crime ring
Weekly mortgage demand drops 6%, as homebuyers remain ‘on the fence’
Here’s how much it can cost for one person to live in 12 major cities globally in 2025
Lori Loughlin lists LA mansion for $16.5 million — a million less than a year ago
U.S. homebuilders raise alarm over tariffs as sentiment falls to 5-month low

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *