New Brooklyn Tower divides NYC with its ‘evil’ ‘Sauron’ vibes

Real Estate

It offers gloom with a view.

The new Brooklyn Tower stands more than 1,000 feet tall and has the luxury amenities of a five-star hotel — but chic custom design isn’t stopping the imposing building from being compared to the headquarters of a villain.

The 93-story residential building is now the tallest in the borough. Although it was inspired by the landmarked Dime Savings Bank it’s attached to, Brooklynites have declared that the dark metallic structure with a neo-art deco crown has “evil vibes.”

Raul Rothblatt, a Brooklyn resident of 30 years, called the building “one more failure of imagination” in NYC.

Earlier in the month, Rothblatt took to Facebook to jokingly brainstorm new names for the building, which listed Dark Tower, Temple of Doom and Sauron’s Tower Minus Eye as options.

“It looks aggressive,” the 58-year-old, who lives in Prospect Heights, told The Post.

Other rankled New Yorkers have taken to social media to complain about the dour tower — which will start accepting rental applications in August — which is blotting the city skyline.


The gloomy new Brooklyn Tower is the borough's tallest skyscraper.
The gloomy new Brooklyn Tower is the borough’s tallest skyscraper.
Paul Martinka

Photo of the Tower of Sauron in the evil land of Mordor from 'The Lord of the Rings.'
Some have compared the tall dark tower to the Tower of Sauron in the evil land of Mordor from “The Lord of the Rings.”
New Line Cinema

Lilly Dancyger, a book editor in Manhattan, likened it to “the headquarters of an evil corporation in a superhero movie” on Twitter, telling The Post via email: “The tower is a hideous blight.”

But perhaps the most popular comparison is to the Tower of Sauron in the evil land of Mordor from “The Lord of the Rings.” In Peter Jackson’s film trilogy, it’s depicted as a foreboding stone obelisk topped with a fiery all-seeing orb.

“It looks like the Eye of Sauron,” Alish Erman, a 36-year-old video producer who lives across the street, told The Post, referring to the Dark Lord’s symbol of omniscience.

The building was designed by SHoP Architects, the team behind the world’s skinniest skyscraper, at 111 W. 57th St. on Billionaires’ Row.

Architect Gregg Pasquarelli told NY1 that SHoP incorporated black steel, copper and huge windows to reflect the borough itself, dubbing it “the Empire State Building of Brooklyn.”

“So, when you look at the obelisk, the building looks solid, not glass,” Pasquarelli said. “And that was an important part for us for making it this landmark with gravitas at the center of Brooklyn.”


Retail Entry, Fleet Street and Flatbush Avenue Extension, Brooklyn Tower.
Nader Tehrani called the design “impeccable.”

Indeed, not everyone thinks it’s casting a shadow over Brooklyn.

Nader Tehrani, a professor at the Cooper Union Irwin S. Chanin School of Architecture, called the design “impeccable,” describing the way that it is “redefining the skyline of Brooklyn” as “unprecedented.”

“I think that generally people have a reaction to the new,” Tehrani told The Post. “I would say there’s an element of conservatism when it comes to people’s vision of their own community.”

He said, historically, there are beloved buildings that weren’t immediately embraced.

“The Eiffel Tower is a great example of a structure that was completely despised,” he said. “The moment that it was built and conceived, it was critiqued for its hostility to the skyline of Paris. Now, it’s unimaginable to think of the skyline of Paris without the Eiffel Tower.”


Dime Savings Dank at street level with tower behind it.
The residential building is built behind the historical Dime Savings Bank of Brooklyn.
Grain London Ltd

A rapidly gentrifying Downtown Brooklyn has certainly contributed to some locals’ ire.

Rothblatt, who describes himself as a “Brooklyn activist,” said the 2004 rezoning of Downtown Brooklyn to allow more residential construction has erased a large part of the area’s immigrant and African-American history.

He cited the city’s efforts to demolish 227 Duffield St. — a stop on the Underground Railroad — as well as the revamping of the Fulton and Albee Square malls, which once served as focal points for Brooklyn’s hip-hop community, as examples.

“Almost everything of the vibrant culture from that era has been replaced,” Rothblatt said. “It didn’t just disappear by accident — it was erased by design.”


Brooklyn Tower at street level looking up.
The condominium residences start on the 53rd floor of the sky-high tower.
Paul Martinka

Rentals in the building will start at $3,407 a month for a studio and $4,350 a month for a one-bedroom, with two months’ free rent reflected in the price. Prices for condos range from $875,000 for a studio to $8 million for a four-bedroom.

SHoP Architects and JDS Development Group did not respond to The Post’s requests for comment.

Villainous or not, at least Brooklyn Tower has character, neighbors say.

“Honestly, I don’t mind it,” said Erman.

“It gives the view from my apartment some drama — I’d rather it look evil than just be another boring rectangle in the skyline.”

Products You May Like

Articles You May Like

Trump’s election win boosts Republican homebuyer optimism
How to Invest $50K in Real Estate As a Beginner
Developer gives first look at planned skyscraper near Grand Central Terminal — but lacks key piece to make it a reality
This thoroughly modern Georgia mansion was one hated by locals — now it’s listed for $40M
Young adults are holding off on moving out of their parents’ house — here’s what’s behind the trend

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *